7 Costly D&D Commission Mistakes (That Waste Your Money)

7 Costly D&D Commission Mistakes (That Waste Your Money)

Picture this: You've just spent $300 on what you thought would be the perfect portrait of your beloved D&D character. Three weeks later, you receive artwork that looks nothing like what you envisioned. The armor is wrong, the expression is completely off, and somehow your fierce half-orc barbarian looks more like a confused accountant.

You're out $300 and back to square one.

After working with hundreds of commissioners over the years, I've seen these same costly mistakes happen over and over again. The worst part? They're all completely avoidable.

These 7 commission mistakes have cost D&D players thousands of dollars and countless hours of frustration. But once you know what they are, you'll never fall victim to them again.

The 7 Money-Wasting Mistakes:

  1. The Vague Description Disaster (costs $50-200 in revisions)
  2. Scope Creep Catastrophe (adds $100-400 unexpectedly)
  3. Wrong Artist, Wrong Style (wastes entire budget)
  4. No Contract Nightmare (zero legal protection)
  5. Revision Hell (endless extra charges)
  6. Timeline Unreality (rush fees of 25-50% extra)
  7. Reference Failure (disappointing results every time)

Mistake #1: The Vague Description Disaster

Typical Cost: $50-200 in additional revision fees, plus weeks of delays

This is the #1 reason commissions go wrong, and it's completely preventable. Here's what usually happens:

Client: "I want a half-orc barbarian who looks tough."

Artist: Creates their interpretation of "tough"

Client: "That's not what I meant at all!"

Why This Costs You Money:

When your description is vague, artists have to guess what you want. When they guess wrong (which they often do), you end up paying for:

  • Multiple revision rounds at $25-50 each
  • Complete restarts if the concept is fundamentally wrong
  • Rush fees if revisions put you behind schedule
  • Artist frustration leading to subpar work

What "Tough" Actually Means to Different People:

  • Battle-scarred veteran: Multiple scars, weathered face, tired but determined eyes
  • Intimidating brute: Massive muscles, scowling expression, aggressive posture
  • Stoic warrior: Calm confidence, steady gaze, controlled strength
  • Feral savage: Wild eyes, unkempt appearance, predatory stance
The Fix: Be specific about everything. Instead of "tough," describe: "Battle-scarred with a prominent scar across the left cheek, weathered hands from years of weapon use, and eyes that show both exhaustion and unwavering determination."

Mistake #2: Scope Creep Catastrophe

Typical Cost: $100-400 in unexpected additional charges

Scope creep happens when you keep adding "just one more thing" to your commission after the price has been agreed upon. It seems innocent enough, but it's a budget killer.

Common Scope Creep Scenarios:

  • Original request: Half-body portrait, simple background
  • Week 1: "Could you add my character's pet raven?"
  • Week 2: "Actually, could we make it a full-body shot?"
  • Week 3: "I just thought of the perfect background scene..."

Result: Your $150 commission is now $400+

The Hidden Costs of Changes:

What seems like a "small addition" often requires the artist to:

  • Rework the entire composition
  • Adjust lighting and shadows
  • Redraw portions already completed
  • Extend their timeline significantly
The Fix: Define everything upfront. Make a complete list of what you want before contacting any artist: character details, pose, background, additional elements, etc. If you think of something later, accept it will cost extra or save it for a future commission.

Mistake #3: Wrong Artist, Wrong Style

Typical Cost: Your entire commission budget wasted on unusable artwork

This mistake ruins more commissions than any other because there's usually no way to fix it. You end up with technically competent art that's completely wrong for your vision.

Common Style Mismatches:

  • Hiring a cute anime artist for your gritty, realistic barbarian
  • Commissioning a realistic portrait artist for cartoony fantasy art
  • Choosing an artist who only does modern characters for your medieval fantasy knight
  • Picking someone who specializes in landscapes for character portraits

Why This Happens:

Players often get excited by an artist's skill level without considering whether their style matches their vision. Just because an artist is talented doesn't mean they're right for your project.

The Fix: Choose artists whose existing work makes you think "I want my character to look like THAT!" Don't try to push artists outside their comfort zone – it rarely works well. Look for artists who already create the style, mood, and genre you're seeking.

Mistake #4: No Contract Nightmare

Typical Cost: Zero legal recourse when things go wrong

Operating without a clear contract is like adventuring without armor – you might get lucky, but when disaster strikes, you're completely defenseless.

What Goes Wrong Without Contracts:

  • Artist disappears with your money and no consequences
  • Unlimited revision demands from the artist's perspective
  • Timeline disputes with no agreed-upon deadlines
  • Usage rights confusion – who can use the art how?
  • Payment disputes with no clear terms
  • Quality disagreements with no defined standards

Real Horror Stories:

I've seen commissioners lose hundreds when artists vanished mid-project. Without contracts, there's often no way to get refunds or completed work.

The Fix: Always work with artists who provide clear terms of service or contracts. These should outline: project scope, timeline, payment schedule, revision policy, cancellation terms, and usage rights. If an artist won't put terms in writing, find someone else.

Mistake #5: Revision Hell

Typical Cost: $25-75 per additional revision round

This mistake happens when commissioners don't understand how revisions work, leading to endless cycles of changes and mounting costs.

How Revision Hell Starts:

  • Assumption: "The artist will keep making changes until it's perfect"
  • Reality: Most artists include 1-2 revision rounds in their base price
  • Problem: Each additional round costs extra
  • Disaster: Your $200 commission becomes $350+ in revision fees

Common Revision Traps:

  • Making piecemeal changes: "Can you adjust the nose? Actually, now the eyes look wrong. Now the mouth doesn't match..."
  • Changing your mind: "I liked the blue better after all"
  • Adding new elements: "I forgot to mention the necklace"
  • Perfectionism paralysis: Never being quite satisfied
The Fix: Understand the revision policy upfront. Make comprehensive feedback in each round rather than piecemeal changes. Accept that no artwork will be 100% perfect – aim for "great" rather than "flawless."

Mistake #6: Timeline Unreality

Typical Cost: 25-50% rush fees, or complete project failure

Unrealistic timeline expectations destroy budgets and relationships with artists. Quality art takes time, and rushing it costs money.

Timeline Disasters:

  • Scenario 1: "I need this for my session next week" (when it normally takes 3-4 weeks)
  • Result: 50% rush fee or declined commission
  • Scenario 2: Accepting an unrealistic timeline promise
  • Result: Rushed, poor-quality artwork or missed deadlines

Realistic Timeline Expectations:

  • Simple headshot: 1-2 weeks
  • Detailed half-body: 2-3 weeks
  • Complex full-body: 3-4 weeks
  • Party portraits: 4-6 weeks
  • Popular artists: Add queue time (often weeks or months)
The Fix: Plan ahead. Start looking for artists well before you need the artwork. If you must rush, budget for the extra cost. Remember: you can have it fast, cheap, or good – pick two.

Mistake #7: Reference Failure

Typical Cost: Disappointing results and wasted budget on unusable art

Failing to provide adequate reference material is like giving someone directions to a place you've never described. The artist will guess, and they'll probably guess wrong.

Reference Failures That Kill Commissions:

  • No visual references: "Just use your imagination"
  • Conflicting references: Realistic face photo + anime body reference
  • Insufficient references: Only a headshot when commissioning full-body art
  • Poor quality references: Blurry, tiny, or unclear images

What Good References Include:

  • Facial features: Close-up references showing the look you want
  • Body type and pose: References showing stance and physique
  • Clothing and armor: Specific examples of style and details
  • Color palette: Examples of colors and how they work together
  • Mood and lighting: References showing the atmosphere you want
The Fix: Create a comprehensive reference collection before commissioning. Use Pinterest, Google Images, or photo collections. Include multiple references for each element. Write clear notes explaining what you like about each reference.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I avoid these mistakes if I'm commissioning for the first time?

Start by creating a detailed brief with all the information you want to communicate. Take time to research artists whose style matches your vision. Don't rush the process, and always work with artists who have clear terms and policies.

What's a reasonable revision policy?

Most professional artists include 1-2 revision rounds in their base price. Additional rounds typically cost $25-75 each. The key is understanding this upfront and making comprehensive feedback in each round.

How do I know if an artist's timeline is realistic?

Quality character art typically takes 1-4 weeks depending on complexity. Be suspicious of promises like "finished in 2 days" unless you're paying significant rush fees. Check the artist's recent work completion times.

What should I do if a commission goes wrong?

Communication is key. Reach out to the artist professionally to discuss the issues. If you have a clear contract, refer to its terms. For serious problems, document everything and consider payment processor dispute resolution.

Protecting Your Investment

These 7 mistakes have cost D&D players thousands of dollars in wasted commissions, extra fees, and unusable artwork. But now you know exactly what to watch out for.

The bottom line: Most commission disasters are preventable with proper planning, clear communication, and realistic expectations. The artists want you to be happy with your commission just as much as you do!

Remember these key principles:

  • Be specific in your descriptions and requests
  • Choose the right artist for your vision and budget
  • Plan ahead with realistic timelines
  • Protect yourself with clear terms and contracts
  • Communicate professionally throughout the process

Want to ensure your next commission goes perfectly? The secret lies in how well you organize and communicate your character's details to the artist.

I've created "The Ultimate Character Blueprint" – a comprehensive template that helps you organize every crucial detail about your character. It's designed to prevent all the communication mistakes that lead to disappointing results and extra costs.

Download your FREE "Ultimate Character Blueprint" template and protect your investment from day one!

 

Explore More Stories